Luxury appliances are significant investments, but when they malfunction, how do you decide between repair and replacement? Here's our professional guidance.
The 50% Rule
A common guideline: if the repair costs more than 50% of replacement, consider replacing. However, this rule doesn't always apply to luxury appliances because: - Premium appliances last longer than standard models - Build quality often justifies higher repair costs - Replacement costs are substantially higher
Age Considerations
Sub-Zero Refrigerators - Expected lifespan: 20+ years - Compressor replacement at year 10 is reasonable - Units under 15 years usually worth repairing
Wolf Ranges - Expected lifespan: 20+ years - Most components readily available - Worth repairing unless cabinet integrity is compromised
Miele Dishwashers - Expected lifespan: 20 years - Pump and motor repairs typically worthwhile - Electronic control boards may indicate end of life
Consider These Factors
Repair Makes Sense When: - Appliance is under 10-12 years old - Issue is isolated to one component - Original purchase included extended warranty - Kitchen design is built around the appliance - Replacement model would require cabinet modifications
Replacement Makes Sense When: - Multiple systems are failing - Energy efficiency would significantly improve - Technology has substantially advanced - Repair parts are discontinued - Previous repairs haven't lasted
Energy Efficiency Reality
Unlike standard appliances, luxury brands typically maintain excellent efficiency throughout their lifespan. Don't replace a working Sub-Zero solely for a newer model's efficiency claims.
Our Honest Assessment
We provide honest repair vs replace recommendations. Sometimes the right answer is a new appliance - we'll tell you when that's the case.